Islamophobia in Canada isn’t new. Consultants say it’s time we face the issue


Following shootings at two mosques in Christchurch, New Zealand that left 49 individuals lifeless and plenty of others injured, some specialists urge Canadians to acknowledge Islamophobia continues to be an ongoing downside at house.

On Jan. 29, 2017, terrorist Alexandre Bissonnette killed six men at a Quebec City mosque and injured two others.

“The truth that the assault was on a mosque strongly means that this was a hate crime and an act of terrorism,” mentioned Ihsaan Gardee, government director of the Nationwide Council of Canadian Muslim (NCCM) in 2017.

“That is the nightmare situation that Canadian Muslims have been dreading.”

Gardee added there’s a “rising and documented local weather” of Islamophobia in Canada.

READ MORE: Christchurch shooting — 49 killed at 2 mosques, 1 man charged with murder

Wanting on the numbers

For years, the NCCM has been monitoring anti-Muslim incidents, from threats to on-line hate, to hate propaganda to vandalism to verbal and bodily assaults.

In 2019, the council famous 9 anti-Muslim incidents, together with hate propaganda in Hamilton, Ont., Ottawa and Cranbrook, B.C., all involving the yellow vest motion.

On Jan. 26, the Edmonton police mentioned their hate crimes unit was known as to analyze after a popular mosque in the city’s northwest end was visited by a group known to police. The NCCM reported different incidents together with hateful letters, robberies and on-line threats.

Haroon Siddiqui, distinguished visiting professor at Ryerson College in Toronto, instructed International Information that even with reported crimes of hate, some nonetheless discover it laborious to imagine Islamophobia is widespread.


“Any time six individuals are murdered in chilly blood in a mosque, we’ve got an issue,” he mentioned. “We don’t want statistics to inform us anything.”

However statistics additionally again up this downside.

Police-reported hate crimes targeting Muslims in Canada tripled between 2012 and 2015, in line with a Statistics Canada report in 2017, regardless of the general numbers of such crimes decreased over the identical interval.

In 2015, police throughout the nation recorded 159 hate crimes targeted at Muslims, up from 45 in 2012, representing a rise of 253 per cent.

A floral tribute is seen on Linwood Avenue close to the Linwood Masjid on March 15 in Christchurch, New Zealand. Credit score: Getty

One other Statistics Canada report launched in 2018 (with information from 2017) discovered Jewish individuals in Canada have been the most important targets for hate crimes (360 hate crime incidents final yr), whereas hate crimes towards Muslims topped 349 incidents.  However Muslims have been a extra outstanding goal when it got here to violent crimes.

“Uttering threats” was the most typical offence, adopted by assault and assault with a weapon, assault inflicting bodily hurt or aggravated assault. Many of those hate crimes occurred in Quebec.

A push to acknowledge Islamophobia

On Friday, the Canadian Muslim Alliance launched an announcement following New Zealand’s mosque assaults, including this act is a transparent show of Islamophobia.

“We commend the assorted ranges of presidency which have acknowledged that Islamophobia is a really actual downside, and we urge them to begin taking sensible steps to stop it,” the statement read.

“Islamophobia is a direct results of the anti-Muslim rhetoric conveyed within the media, by means of which people like these are radicalized. We attraction to the Canadian, Quebec and municipal governments to face towards any such hate speech. Phrases matter.”

On Jan. 29, Quebec premier François Legault instructed reporters there was “no Islamophobia in Quebec,” including the province would not have a national day to combat the problem. The following day, after vital criticism, Legault backtracked on his feedback.

“Islamophobia, xenophobia, racism and hate exist, however not an Islamophobic present,” an aide to Legault instructed reporters. “Quebec is just not Islamophobic or racist.”

READ MORE: New Zealand police search home in Dunedin after mosque shooting

In Ottawa, the Commons heritage committee really useful Jan. 29 as a “national day of remembrance and action on Islamophobia and other forms of religious discrimination.,” whereas Toronto Mayor John Tory introduced the identical week that the town was proclaiming Jan. 29 a day of remembrance and motion on Islamophobia.

However following Thursday’s assaults in New Zealand (and different ant-Muslim assaults earlier than it), Siddiqui mentioned one other downside is how individuals of affect speak about anti-Muslim crimes.

On Friday, following the taking pictures in New Zealand, Trump confronted criticism on Twitter for leaving out the word “Muslim” in his message to followers, whereas Conservative chief Andrew Scheer acquired similar backlash by not using the words “Muslim” or “mosques” in his first tweet. He later added each phrases in an extended assertion on Friday.

Siddiqui defined it additional provides to a bigger narrative that Islamophobia doesn’t exist.

WATCH: Pakistani Muslims protest towards anti-Muslim violence




“It exhibits you any try to spotlight Islamophobia goes to be put down as a result of individuals wish to keep denial or different individuals wish to maintain lots of people in denial,” he instructed International Information.

The NCCM additionally launched an announcement, calling out politicians not mentioning “Muslim” or “mosque” in their commentary. 

“It’s important that our elected leaders communicate out clearly and unequivocally towards such assaults and identify them for the Islamophobic terrorist assaults that they’re,” Gardee mentioned.

READ MORE: Quebec City Muslim community reliving terror, pain after hearing about New Zealand mosque attacks

Faisal Bhabha, an affiliate professor and human rights professional at Osgoode Corridor Regulation Faculty at York College in Toronto, mentioned even utilizing the phrase Islamophobia to explain these acts is regarding to some.

“There are those that are anxious that it would imply one thing that may lead [Canada] to develop public coverage and legislation,” he instructed International Information. “I feel those that are involved about Islamophobia is likely to be involved that it’s going for use in an improper method the way in which to stifle speech or they is likely to be racists.”

A number of hundred individuals march in solidarity for the victims of the mosque taking pictures in Quebec Metropolis on February 5, 2017. Credit score Getty.

For a majority of Canadians, he added, hate speech is just not nicely understood. “Tright here’s a really slim definition of hate speech within the legal code which is the one authorized definition we’ve got,” he continued.

“Whenever you study someone’s attitudes about what they consider individuals, you discover that all of them have deeply discriminatory attitudes in the direction of individuals. And so there’s a complete lot of unconscious racism that exists.”

Anti-Muslim assaults ‘usually are not shocking’

Bhabha added whereas it was inspiring for the nation to face in solitary with Canadian Muslims following the Quebec Metropolis mosque taking pictures and even the assaults in New Zealand, crimes like this don’t shock him.

“We all know that when a horrible act towards an identifiable group occurs, it creates virtually a kind of social permission,” he mentioned. “And even worse [some] don’t see the connection between these excessive acts and the on a regular basis odd attitudes and actions that contribute to the situations that give rise to these excessive acts.”

He mentioned with taking pictures like this one, in addition to Quebec Metropolis and a number of other different examples within the U.S., there must be bigger discussions across the radicalization of younger white males in our society.

How can we conquer it?

Siddiqui mentioned conquering one thing as complicated as Islamophobia begins with recognizing it exists, in addition to the wrongs we’ve got completed as a rustic.

Bhabha finds it troublesome to imagine some Canadians simply don’t work together with Muslims on their day-to-day. “I actually assume that multiculturalism as a coverage has did not the extent that Canadians don’t really actually know one another,” he mentioned. “As a result of if we did, we wouldn’t have the the dimensions of those kinds of issues rising.”

Talking with International Information on Friday, Luqman Ahmed, an Imam with the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jama’at of Canada, mentioned acts of anti-Muslim bigotry are a results of misconceptions and hate mongering towards Muslims.

“I imagine each particular person has the suitable to imagine as they might select and there are individuals who would criticize Islam, disagree with Islamic religion, and that i don’t count on everybody to agree with my religion,” he mentioned. “However we’ve got to distinguish between critiquing an ideology in an ethical method vs. spreading hatred towards individuals.”

READ MORE:  Montreal, Quebec City police on high alert following New Zealand mosque shootings

Ahmed mentioned anti-Muslim bigotry isn’t rampant in Canada, including nearly all of Canadians stand in solidarity with Muslims when such assaults occur, however there are particular parts in society we have to sort out.

“I’ve seen that plenty of Muslim organizations attain out to individuals, to assist them perceive Islamic religion and Muslims,” he continued, including his mosque has open homes encouraging everybody locally to fulfill Muslim neighbours.”

He added the issue is when individuals generalize actions from a number of members of a religion.

“Nearly all of Muslims are peaceable and wish to reside in an open free society like everybody else.”

arti.patel@globalnews.ca

— With information from Canadian Press, Amy Minsky, Jesse Ferreras, Abigail Bimman

© 2019 International Information, a division of Corus Leisure Inc.





Source link